Talks of Record Both Sides

Questions

Hard questions, with one video for each side.

Should cities build networks of single-lane tunnels?

Where they split Whether faster, cheaper boring makes a car-width Loop scalable, or whether capacity is still capped by vehicle size.

Will AI make wealth inequality much worse?

Where they split Whether AI as it is being built will push wealth toward capital owners, or whether market incentives will make it cheap, widely used, and good for wages.

Is advanced AI an existential risk?

Same roomBengio and Tegmark vs Mitchell and LeCunMunk Debate on Artificial Intelligence | Bengio & Tegmark vs. Mitchell & LeCun2023 · Policy-Relevant Science & Technology · 1:47:20

Where they split Whether current methods lead to an unaligned superintelligence, or whether that extinction case is overdrawn.

Will superintelligence arrive in a sudden takeoff?

Same roomYudkowsky vs Hanson, Jane Street, 2011Yudkowsky vs Hanson, Singularity Debate2017 · Jane Street · 1:38:23

Where they split Speed and location of the takeoff, a fast local explosion versus a drawn-out economic transition.

Will AGI arrive around 2029?

Where they split Whether Kurzweil's long-held date still holds, or whether scaling current systems will not get there.

Is degrowth required to stabilize the climate?

Same roomDegrowth vs green growth, Oxford Smith SchoolHow to Save the Planet: Degrowth vs Green Growth?2022 · OxfordSmithSchool · 1:33:05

Where they split Whether growth can be decoupled from environmental harm, or whether degrowth is required.

Can renewables alone decarbonize the energy system?

Where they split Whether a renewables-only grid works at low cost, or whether it uses too much land and needs nuclear.

Should rich countries open their borders?

Where they split Whether the gains in world output dominate, or whether costs fall too heavily on low-skill workers and budgets.

Is rising inequality mainly a problem of capital?

Where they split Whether capital outpacing growth is the engine, or whether ideas and ethics drove the enrichment.

Is longtermism a sound way to do good?

Where they split Whether longtermism is a sound moral frame, or a dangerous one.

Is human aging already being reversed?

Where they split Whether lab results show aging is treatable now, or whether those reversal claims do not hold up.

Do humans have free will?

Same roomDennett vs Sapolsky, How To AcademyDo We Have Freewill? / Daniel Dennett VS Robert Sapolsky2024 · How To Academy · 1:07:41

Where they split Whether biology rules out free will, or whether a free will worth wanting survives determinism.

Has progress stalled since the 1970s?

Where they split Whether innovation and median growth slowed, or whether the long trend of longer, safer, more prosperous lives is still running.

Are phones a major cause of teen mental illness?

Where they split Whether those tools drove the rise in teen distress, or whether the evidence points to other causes.

Is eating animals ethically wrong?

Where they split Whether factory farming is a moral disaster we should leave, or whether animal foods should remain.

Should we research solar geoengineering?

Where they split Whether a cheap way to halt warming should be studied, or whether climate engineering is too dangerous to pursue.